Since about 2009 a non-public group of males that had jobs in journalism, public relations, graphic design, and media training in France have been harassing feminine journalists and activists. These males had been a part of a secret Fb group that referred to themselves because the “Ligue du LOL” or in English talking phrases the “LOL League”. This group contained about 30 members primarily all being males. For nearly the final decade this group of males went about harassing ladies via a mess of how together with establishing pretend interviews, photoshopping these ladies onto inappropriate and pornographic photographs, attacking them on a number of social media platforms, orchestrating focused harassment campaigns, and even to the extent of demise threats. That is only a brief checklist of what these males truly did and the way far they really went to hurt these ladies. Not solely did they assault simply ladies however in addition they went after feminists, members of the LGBTQ neighborhood, and in addition writers of colour and completely different ethnic backgrounds. These ladies both deleted their social media accounts or stayed off it utterly however the harassment adopted them offline as properly. Behind all of this was the creator of the group, Vincent Glad. Glad, a journalist for Liberation which is a left-wing and progressive publication acknowledged that this group was meant only for trolling and that this “Was a monster he had misplaced management of”. Many of those males concerned on this group have now turn into distinguished members of their media publications. Not solely has most of the people confirmed a distaste for the way these males carried themselves however the French Authorities has even gotten concerned stating that they wish to additional legal guidelines to guard folks from harassment on social media. Together with this, anti-hate teams reminiscent of SOS Racisme has come forth and acknowledged that they need a judicial investigation into this matter.
Mockingly, this group was uncovered by Glad’s personal employer Liberation in February of 2019. This occurred after the fact-checking division responded to a reader’s query in regards to the group’s existence and revealed a chunk chronicling the group’s actions over time. Quickly after this piece was revealed dozens of victims got here forth with their tales of abuse and harassment that they’d succumbed to over time on the hand of this group. These media publications reminiscent of Liberation and Les Inrockuptibles have since suspended or fired the boys who had been concerned within the harassment and have began their very own inner investigations.
There are various folks instantly affected by this case they embrace the boys concerned within the LOL League, the media publications they labored for, the ladies who obtained the harassment, together with the French authorities. All of those folks have a direct reference to the case or have a priority with the actions of the group.
this case from an Individualist perspective it may be seen that these males acted unethically. Individualism is outlined as that enterprise actions ought to maximize income for the proprietor’s of the enterprise, however achieve this inside the regulation. With taking a look at this case as an entire it may be seen that the actions of those males had a totally unfavourable impact on their very own publications. The unfavourable publicity they’ve introduced onto their publication has a direct correlation to the income that these corporations will see. As many of those males labored for progressive and left-leaning publications the shoppers and subscribers of them will now have no real interest in persevering with their involvement with an organization that had worker’s performing with a whole disregard for what they’re supposed to face for and for a corporation that did nothing when victims got here forth with complaints.
From a Utilitarianist perspective, this case doesn’t conform to any of the rules that the speculation helps. This concept is outlined as that happiness or pleasure are the one issues of intrinsic worth and that we must result in these qualities in all succesful beings. These males confirmed no regard for the happiness of those ladies and stole each likelihood these ladies had at being joyful. The shortage of take care of these folks’s happiness was current within the methods the boys went about their actions and what precisely they had been doing. They attacked these ladies with fixed harassment whether or not it being on social media or offline there was no escape for these ladies ever. These males valued getting a fast chortle and placing different folks down slightly than valuing different folks’s happiness as an entire.
A Kantian would take a look at this case and look at it as being unethical. The Kantian concept is outlined as all the time act in ways in which respect and honor people and their selections together with that you shouldn’t lie, cheat, manipulate, or hurt others to get your manner. This concept relies on performing with “good will” slightly than instantly worrying in regards to the penalties of your actions. Together with this, the speculation helps that individuals ought to deal with others as an finish and slightly not as a way to additional their very own trigger. These males instantly used these ladies as a way to additional their very own careers by placing the ladies down and always degrading them. The boys additionally acted with no “good will” with their actions that they offered. In addition they didn’t act in any with respect in the direction of these ladies by repeatedly thrashing down harassment and hurt in the direction of them. These males acted utterly out of the ethical system and confirmed no motivation that was rational for his or her actions.
this case from the Advantage concept it might even be acknowledged that this case was unethical. This concept focuses on the first worth of character traits that promote wellness and flourishing of people inside a society. The rule that goes together with this moral concept states that individuals ought to act to as embody a wide range of virtuous or good character traits and in order to keep away from vicious or unhealthy character traits. These traits could be break up into two classes, vices, and virtues. Vices are described as being immoral and embrace misconduct whereas virtues are described as conduct or traits that present a excessive ethical commonplace. The boys concerned failed to indicate any virtues however slightly utterly going in opposition to virtues reminiscent of justice, braveness, and compassion in the direction of these ladies. A really very important vice current on this case is that these males confirmed selfishness as they solely cared about their very own private revenue and pleasure they obtained from placing these ladies down.
The French media and its publications want to reply with a direct plan to take relating to this case. There are various methods they’ll go about this motion plan however there are particular steps they should take to make sure that this by no means occurs once more and to guard the ladies concerned. First off these media publications want to return out and publicly apologize for the best way their staff have acted. Subsequent, they need to conduct their very own thorough investigation into instantly what occurred and who precisely was concerned. After they uncover what precisely occurred they should make sure to set an instance and lay down hefty suspensions or a whole firing of the personnel concerned. These corporations as an entire also needs to implement a zero-tolerance coverage for harassment. This may forestall and discourage folks from even entertaining the thought of performing like this. One other large step on this course of could be to place extra stress on the French authorities to place down legal guidelines to guard folks from harassment over social media and in individual. Lastly and perhaps most significantly there must be extra stress on media corporations to rent extra ladies. Out of the 470 high government jobs within the media lower than 1 / 4 are owned by ladies. With fixing this concept it will possibly begin to usher within the concept of gender equality and assist to forestall harassment like this from ever occurring once more. All of those steps of this plan come collectively to put down the steps that these media corporations must take to forestall any harassment or an issue of this magnitude to ever happen once more.
Breeden, Aurelien. “Fb Group of French Journalists Harassed Girls for Years.” The New York Occasions, The New York Occasions, 12 Feb. 2019, www.nytimes.com/2019/02/12/world/europe/la-ligue-du-lol-sexual-harassment.html.
Bremner, Charles. “We Are Sexist Trolls, French Media Chiefs Admit.” World | The Occasions, The Occasions, 12 Feb. 2019, www.thetimes.co.uk/article/we-are-sexist-trolls-french-media-chiefs-admit-3p3clbl9k.
Chrisafis, Angelique. “French Media in Disaster as They Face Their Personal #MeToo Second.” The Guardian, Guardian Information and Media, 15 Feb. 2019, www.theguardian.com/world/2019/feb/15/french-media-crisis-faces-own-metoo-moment-ligue-du-lol.
“Ligue Du LOL: Secret Group of French Journalists Focused Girls.” BBC Information, BBC, 12 Feb. 2019, www.bbc.com/information/world-europe-47206248.
North, Anna. “The #MeToo Motion and Its Evolution, Defined.” Vox, Vox, 11 Oct. 2018, www.vox.com/identities/2018/10/9/17933746/me-too-movement-metoo-brett-kavanaugh-weinstein.
Salazar, Heather. The Enterprise Ethics Case Guide. n.d.
Subscribe to our Project Management newsletter to get the latest news and articles delivered to your inbox!